A contractor recently asked us “what is a hard insurance
market?” His insurance was not up for renewal yet. We explained
simply…it is when it is HARD to get insurance at an affordable price. Now that
his insurance renewed, he fully understands!
Like many contractors, the increase in his insurance was
more than the profit made last year. That is a powerful statement and very
troubling to the industry as a whole. As competitive as the construction
industry already is, and as tight as the margins already are, it is difficult
for many contractors to remain in business with insurance costs skyrocketing.
The greatest problem is that the rising insurance costs are
not equally reflected in bid prices for all contractors. Insurance is
unlike any other cost of construction that contractors encounter. Contractors
are used to rising costs. It happens all the time. The cost of steel, lumber
and concrete is constantly on the rise, and contractors adjust bids
accordingly, sometimes even having escalation provisions in their contract to
guard against a sudden rise. Not so with insurance.
Since insurance only renews once a year, in a bidding
atmosphere, contractor “A” might be using old insurance rates to bid against
contractor “B”, while the insurance for contractor “B” may have recently
tripled. If contractor “B” is going to compete with contractor “A”, the only
thing that can give is bottom-line profit.
This sort of delayed reaction to rising insurance costs in
a very competitive market causes those forced to absorb costs earlier to lose
more. And since it takes the market an entire year for all participants to
experience a spike in insurances, it also takes a full year for all of the
participants to build in those rising costs into higher bid prices. In
addition, when rising insurance costs in a hard market extend beyond a year,
the problem is perpetuated.
To further the disparity, other considerations made by the
carriers come into play that also cause an uneven playing ground. More
than ever, insurance carriers are requesting financial statements of the
insured. Certainly, a weak financial statement can result in a decline of
coverage while another contractor may receive a quote.
The type of work performed is another huge variable. To
really uneven the playing field, those contractors that are performing a mix
of different types of work can have “the well poisoned” by one class of work
that is undesirable. All you have to do is talk to a contractor that even
touched any residential work along with the other 95% of its jobs.
By now, many insurance buyers have experienced the effects
of the hard insurance market, some on the second time around. Nowhere has
the impact of the difficult market conditions hit harder than the construction
industry. At a minimum, this has meant higher insurance premiums — and in many
cases, restrictions or exclusions of coverage.
The reasons for the rate increases are many, and include:
-
Years of under pricing by insurance companies, magnified by
the economic slowdown, have resulted in insurers looking for more premium
dollars for risk assumed;
-
Increasing legal and medical costs;
-
Catastrophic losses incurred by the insurance industry in
recent years;
-
Explosion of construction defect claims.
For contractors, these price increases have been amplified
by the fact that they are occurring at a time when acquiring work is extremely
difficult due to competition and availability of work, and individual project
and company profit margins are generally shrinking. With premiums and
exclusions out of our control, the insurance crisis should prompt many to take
a long, hard look at how our company operates. It is important to realize that
there are some things you can do to help reduce the cost of insurance and to
make you company more attractive to underwriters.
While business owners have always been cost conscious,
contractors are seeing these premium increases and are looking to their
insurance agents for advice about how to control this expense. This leads
to our 15 ways to reduce construction insurance costs. |